Re: DS and FCP

[Paul Neal <dsartist(at)gmail.com>]

Well put!!

On 10/31/05, Kristen Maxwell <kris(at)evilcyborg.com> wrote:

I agree that Final Cut's democratization of editing tools (to a larger
extent than Adobe did with Premiere) has chruned up a lot of "dregs,"
and along the same lines there are producers who want to exclusively use
FCP and drive the rates down.

However, I know that the inverse has been true for a long time- yahoos
who can afford an AVID system and a Beta deck (probably DVCPRO these
days) go out charging 100+ hourly bench rates and don't know a story arc
from a hole in the ground (you know, these are the yutzes who all have
spinning globes as their logos). I've worked for these kinds of people,
and they're no less annoying or damaging to the field of editing than a
punk kid who "knows how to edit" because he can drag n drop a clip into
a timeline.

I think that we as editors have the burden of dispelling the myths about
the platform determining the value, and therefore the price of our
services, to our customers. We can't really expect them not to want to
pay less for a FCP editor when there are still plenty of editors out
there inflating their prices because they have Avids. If we really want
to have people value our skills and services, then we have to move
beyond the old model of "selling the system."

In my mind, an editor who is nimble enough to take a project in and out
of Final Cut, Motion, Shake, After Effects and Soundtrack to get the job
done is worth more than the staunch Avid user who only ever uses the
defaults on all the tools. Again, this is not because FCP is any better
or worse than Avid- it's all in how you drive it.

Kristen Maxwell
www.thecacophone.com


--
"It's not that I fear failure. I just fear failure in front of other people."
- Robert Rodriguez, "Rebel Without a Crew"

---
Subscribe? E-mail Majordomo(at)Softimage.COM with the following text in body: subscribe ds
Unsubscribe? E-Mail Majordomo(at)Softimage.COM with the following text in body: unsubscribe ds