RE: Here comes the Pinnacle Stuff

[Marc Fisher <MFisher(at)mvfinc.com>]

OK, so who's going to jump with us? ship that is. paul and i have had this discussion, as i'm sure several of you have, about the real reason why FCP isn't the mainstay in most places.. if you don't already know, then do some research. i would love to see that fact change, cause frankly, i am getting tired of making excuses, esp whenit's always being compared to FCP or , like the previous email from scott, just about everything else does everything else.

 

Argh!!!! (in the flavor of charlie brown missing the football, again!)

 

Marc

---

From: Paul Neal [mailto:dsartist(at)gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, November 10, 2005 8:31 AM
To: DS(at)Softimage.COM
Subject: Re: Here comes the Pinnacle Stuff

Ya know...the description below is the biggest seller (to ME) for learning/purchasing FCP.  I have been avoiding RE-learning FCP (used it back in the day...v1.2) for many reasons, but after reading Scott's description of WHAT you can purchase to do whatever flavor of editing, it only makes sense to invest in FCP.

 

I want to say it's a shame...but I think it's because I feel (now) that Avid really is watering down their product instead of bringing them together.

 

wow. (shock AND awe...with disgust mixed in)

 

Paul

 

On 11/9/05, Scott Malkie <ltc.vitc(at)gmail.com> wrote:

/rant - apologies in advance!

So,

If I shoot DV, edit DV, and deliver to DV / DVDs I can use:
Avid Xpress DV + Avid DVD OR Avid Liquid OR Final Cut Pro.
If I shoot Digibeta / SP, edit 601, and deliver to Digibeta / SP I can use:
Avid Xpress Pro OR Avid Liquid Pro OR Avid MCA Adrenaline OR Avid DS OR Final Cut Pro.
If I shoot HDV, edit HDV, and deliver on HDV I can use:
Avid Xpress Pro HD (only on PC) OR Avid Liquid Pro OR Final Cut Pro.
If I shoot HDCam, edit HD, and deliver on HDCam/D5:
I can use Avid MCA Adrenaline (compressed) OR Avid Symphony Nitris OR Avid DS OR Avid Liquid Chrome OR Final Cut Pro
If I shoot HDCam SR, edit 4:4:4, and deliver on HDCam SR I can use:
Discreet smoke OR Final Cut Pro.