Re: objects not connecting to right groups in custom operator

["Aloys Baillet" <aloys.baillet(at)gmail.com>]

Yes indeed, you need one port by portgroup.
But I think I'm missing something in your set-up, I don't see why it wouldn't work!
You can send me your current code offline if you want.

Cheers,

Aloys

On 11/4/06, Mathieu Leclaire <mleclair(at)hybride.com> wrote:

OK, let me see if I understand correctly. Instead of creating 3 groups I should create 6 and connect the primitive and kinematics to different groups? I've tried that but it logs me this now:

 

//INFO : nb groups in Operator = 6

//INFO : nb ports in Group 0 = 2

//INFO : nb Instances in Group 0 = 1

//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is sphere.polymsh

//INFO : port 0 instance 1 is

//INFO : port 1 instance 0 is sphere.kine.global

//INFO : port 1 instance 1 is

//INFO : nb ports in Group 1 = 1

//INFO : nb Instances in Group 1 = 1

//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is

//INFO : nb ports in Group 2 = 1

//INFO : nb Instances in Group 2 = 1

//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is

//INFO : nb ports in Group 3 = 1

//INFO : nb Instances in Group 3 = 1

//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is

//INFO : nb ports in Group 4 = 1

//INFO : nb Instances in Group 4 = 1

//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is

//INFO : nb ports in Group 5 = 1

//INFO : nb Instances in Group 5 = 1

//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is

 

Am I still misunderstanding something? I don't understand why it still connects the primitive and kinamatic on the first group and doesn't connect the other groups. Something weird is happening and I can't figure out why.

-----Original Message-----
From: owner-xsi(at)Softimage.COM [mailto:owner-xsi(at)Softimage.COM]On Behalf Of Aloys Baillet
Sent: Thursday, November 02, 2006 4:48 PM
To: XSI(at)Softimage.COM
Subject: Re: objects not connecting to right groups in custom operator

Hi Mathieu,

Bad news, SICO don't allow multiple ports on dynamic port groups.
I logged a bug to Softimage for this one (UDEV00226149).
It's actually a "documented" problem of the ConnectToGroup method:

Note: This method only works for Self-Installed Custom Operators if there is a single port inside the port group. This limitation exists because you can only pass a single object in the Object argument.

As a workaround, you can try using the UpdateConnectOnOp command, or split your portgroups so that you only have one dynamic port per port group.

I know, it's a pain! You can log it to the support as well so that someone takes care of it...

Cheers,

Aloys

On 11/3/06, Mathieu Leclaire <mleclair(at)hybride.com> wrote:

OK... here I am again a bit confused about Self-Installed Custom Operators.
Sorry for all the code but I need to show it to explain what I'm doing.
First I'll explain what I'm after. I need my operator to have access to the
geometry of at least 3 objects:

1 - The deforming object that will be deformed by the operator.
2 - The target object that is used to drive the deformed object.
3 - A list of obstacles.

So I'm trying to set-up 3 groups for each one of those components and pass
the primitive and global kinematics to the operator. Here is part of the
code when I try to assign the operator :


        CustomOperator newOp =
Application().GetFactory().CreateObject(L"test_SICO");
        assert( newOp.IsValid() ) ;
        newOp.PutDebug(0);

        // Create group 0 for the deformed mesh
        newOp.AddPortGroup( L"Group_0", 1, 1 );
        newOp.AddIOPortByClassID ( siPrimitiveID, L"IO_Geom", 0  ) ;
        newOp.AddInputPortByClassID( siKinematicStateID, L"In_Kine", 0  ) ;

        // Create group 1 for the target mesh
        newOp.AddPortGroup( L"Group_1", 1, 1 );
        newOp.AddInputPortByClassID( siPrimitiveID, L"In_Geom", 1  ) ;
        newOp.AddInputPortByClassID( siKinematicStateID, L"In_Kine", 1  ) ;

        // Obstable group will allow between 1 and 1000 objects
        newOp.AddPortGroup( L"Group_2", 1, 1000 );
        newOp.AddInputPortByClassID( siPrimitiveID, L"In_Geom", 2  ) ;
        newOp.AddInputPortByClassID( siKinematicStateID, L"In_Kine", 2  ) ;

        // Connection time
        long instance = 0;
        CStatus st;
        //primitive of deformed object to Group_0... deformedMeshX3D is an
X3DObject
        st = newOp.ConnectToGroup( 0 , (CRef)deformedMeshX3D.GetActivePrimitive(),
instance ) ;
        if ( st != CStatus::OK )
        {
                Application().LogMessage(L"error connecting primitive of deformed
object");
                return st;
        }
        //kinematics of deformed object to Group_0... deformedMeshX3D is an
X3DObject
        st = newOp.ConnectToGroup( 0 ,
(CRef)(deformedMeshX3D.GetKinematics().GetGlobal()), instance ) ;
        if ( st != CStatus::OK )
        {
                Application().LogMessage(L"error connecting kinematics of deformed
object");
                return st;
        }
        //primitive of target object to Group_1... targetMeshX3D is an X3DObject
        st = newOp.ConnectToGroup( 1 , (CRef)targetMeshX3D.GetActivePrimitive(),
instance ) ;
        if ( st != CStatus::OK )
        {
                Application().LogMessage(L"error connecting primitive of target object");
                return st;
        }
        //kinematics of target object to Group_1... targetMeshX3D is an X3DObject
        st = newOp.ConnectToGroup( 1 ,
(CRef)(targetMeshX3D.GetKinematics().GetGlobal()), instance ) ;
        if ( st != CStatus::OK )
        {
                Application().LogMessage(L"error connecting kinematics of target object");
                return st;
        }

        // Connect all the obstacles to Group_2
        for (long i=0; i<obstaclesCount; i++)
        {
                CRef tempRef(inObstacles[i]);
                if (!tempRef.IsValid() )
                {
                        // This wasn't a valid XSI object
                        newOp.Disconnect(false) ;       //Cleanup
                        return CStatus::InvalidArgument ;
                }
                X3DObject inObstacle(inObstacles[i]);
                Primitive obstaclePrim = inObstacle.GetActivePrimitive();

                CRef l_ref(obstaclePrim.GetRef());
                CStatus st( newOp.ConnectToGroup(  2, l_ref, instance ) );
                assert( st.Succeeded() ) ;
                //assert( instance == i ) ;

                KinematicState obstacleKine = inObstacle.GetKinematics().GetGlobal();

                CRef l_ref2(obstacleKine.GetRef());
                CStatus st2( newOp.ConnectToGroup(  2, l_ref2, instance ) );
                assert( st2.Succeeded() ) ;
                //assert( instance == i ) ;
        }


So this is how I'm connecting them but it gives me weird results... If I log
what's in the different groups and port inside the operators update callback
function:


XSIPLUGINCALLBACK CStatus test_SICO_Update( CRef& in_ctxt )
{
        OperatorContext ctxt( in_ctxt );
        Operator op(ctxt.GetSource());

        long nbPorts, nbInst, numGroup = op.GetNumPortGroups();

        Application().LogMessage(L"nb groups in Operator = "+CString(numGroup ));

        for (long ii=0; ii<numGroup; ii++){
                nbPorts = op.GetNumPortsInGroup(ii);
                nbInst = op.GetNumInstancesInGroup(ii);
                Application().LogMessage(L"nb ports in Group "+CString(ii)+L" =
"+CString(nbPorts));
                Application().LogMessage(L"nb Instances in Group "+CString(ii)+L" =
"+CString(nbInst));
                for (long jj=0; jj<nbPorts; jj++)
                        for (long kk=0; kk<nbPorts; kk++) {
                                SIObject objet = ctxt.GetInputValue( ii, jj, kk );
                                Application().LogMessage(L"port "+CString(jj)+L" instance
"+CString(kk)+L" is "+objet.GetFullName());
                        }
        }
        CRef output = ctxt.GetOutputTarget();
        return CStatus::OK;
}


here's what's being logged if the 3 objects attached are sphere (deformed
object), sphere1 (target object) and sphere2 (obstacles) :


//INFO : nb groups in Operator = 3
//INFO : nb ports in Group 0 = 3
//INFO : nb Instances in Group 0 = 2
//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is sphere.polymsh
//INFO : port 0 instance 1 is sphere.kine.global
//INFO : port 0 instance 2 is
//INFO : port 1 instance 0 is sphere1.polymsh
//INFO : port 1 instance 1 is sphere1.kine.global
//INFO : port 1 instance 2 is
//INFO : port 2 instance 0 is sphere2.polymsh
//INFO : port 2 instance 1 is sphere2.kine.global
//INFO : port 2 instance 2 is
//INFO : nb ports in Group 1 = 2
//INFO : nb Instances in Group 1 = 2
//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is sphere.polymsh
//INFO : port 0 instance 1 is sphere.kine.global
//INFO : port 1 instance 0 is sphere1.polymsh
//INFO : port 1 instance 1 is sphere1.kine.global
//INFO : nb ports in Group 2 = 2
//INFO : nb Instances in Group 2 = 2
//INFO : port 0 instance 0 is
//INFO : port 0 instance 1 is
//INFO : port 1 instance 0 is
//INFO : port 1 instance 1 is


...not only is the objects not connected to the right groups, but it
actually logs 3 times those parameters which shows that the operator is
called 3 times on each change of frame where only sphere's position is
animated. What am I doing wrong? Why are the connections not at the desired
group and ports?



Mathieu Leclaire
R&D Programmer
Hybride Technologies


====================================
"There's only one way you can fail, and that's to quit."

-- Brian Hays
====================================
Want to live a happy life and help make the world a better place? Come and
Play The Critical Mass Game:
http://www.criticalmassgame.com/?taf=cc875f0b




---
Unsubscribe? Mail Majordomo(at)Softimage.COM with the following text in body:
unsubscribe xsi

--
Aloys Baillet - XSI Technical Director
Character Dpt - Animal Logic
--

-- 
Aloys Baillet - XSI Technical Director
Character Dpt - Animal Logic
--