Re: Reference model limitations?

Date : Thu, 26 Jul 2007 10:56:34 -0500
To : XSI(at)Softimage.COM
From : Jeffrey Dates <jdates(at)kungfukoi.com>
Subject : Re: Reference model limitations?
>...so far I am forced to admit that there is no workaround to my problem except committing to local which is something I translate into pipeline failure.

 I couldn't agree with this sentiment more.

It sounds like you're doing the most with Ref models that can be done in a pipeline. Use them as reference models as long as possible to facilitate changes, and localize them when left with no other choice. ( usually during lighting and FX )  This is how the character work I've done usually goes.

Often times, I'd keep a scene file that maintains the Reference, and a corresponding scene that is localized for render.  If character changes do get propagated, it's just a matter of determining which is less work... going back to the referenced scene and redoing my localized work, or applying the changes to my local scene.  Neither is ideal.

The other option is to either manually, or via scripting, switch out local models and replace animation via clips or something similar.   I've just found this prone to user error. ( or scripting errors ), but find that a majority of the studios just simply work this way.

As for your specific issue of collision objects on referenced cloth....  Basically, cloth sim/collission should be the last step on your pipeline before render... 
You might try localizing just the cloth as a seperate model and constraining it to your ref. model.  Or localizing it, colliding it, and baking it with a point cache.  But in the end, just going local is the least headache... 

There is very little discussion about  Reference models  in an XSI pipeline, and find that very unfortunate.  Modular, Referenced Data is so powerful, and ideal for non-linear production, it astounds me it's not the 'norm', or more heavily implemented in the software.  

Hopefully someone else is pushing this workflow in areas I'm unfamiliar with...    I'd sure welcome it!


--

Jeffrey Dates
www.kungfukoi.com
214.280.4353

Search the XSI List archives here or use the advanced search form to search across mailing lists. Searching help is available.
This site supposedly brought to you by Benjamin Grosser and the Imaging Technology Group.